Thursday, August 16, 2007

Is Castilian Different than Spanish?


A: The Oxford English Dictionary differentiates Spanish and Castilian, noting that Castilian is the Spanish spoken in Spain. But español and castellano in Spanish are synonymous. Castellano or español is the language of Spain and its former colonial territories in America, most of which became independent republics in the 19th century. Notice that I wrote español, without a capital E. Languages, nationalities, days of the week and months are not capitalized in Spanish. We say inglés for English, francés for French, polaco for Polish, ruso for Russian, farsi for Iranian and vietnamita for Vietnamese.

Oscar Wilde said England and the United States were two countries separated by the same language. Spain and Latin America (including Hispanics in the US) are two worlds joined by one language. Formal Spanish is the same everywhere. There are colloquial differences, of course. Los argentinos y los uruguayos pronounce the ll, the y the g as English speakers pronounce the sh in she. Some bolivianos and ecuatorianos pronounce the ll as the l in Leonor. Most other Spanish-speakers pronounce the ll as the y in yo-yo. Latin Americans pronounce the c, s and z as the English s in Sam, but in Spain the z sounds more like the th in thanks. In Latin America both v and b sound identical to the English b in boy.

2 comments:

R. Senserrich said...

Just a quick note, regarding "castellano". In Spain itself, how you call a language is not a trivial matter. As several regions have their own different languages (Vasque, Galllego, Catalan), saying you "habla español" is a bit misleading; a guy from Barcelona is "español" (that is, from Spain) but he doesn´t have "castellano" as his mother tongue; he speaks Catalan with his family and friends.

Of course, everybody in Barcelona that speaks Catalan is pretty much perfectly bilingual, but still, it is a funny distinction. Spanish, the language, is usually not called "español" in Spain itself.

Chus Piñeiro said...

I don't agree with you egocrata, I'm Galician and bilingual, both Castillian or Spanish and Galician are my mother tongues, we use both languages everyday.

We use to call it Castellano because Catalan, Euskera, Gallego, Castellano and even all the different dialects not recogniced as official languages are "Español".